skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

The food was good, but they did mess up 4 of our 6 orders. Menu says kids can upgrade to fries wit
The food was good, but they did mess up 4 of our 6 orders. Menu says kids can upgrade to fries with their kids mea for $.29, and the person taking our order said we could. We also ordered a combination (all you can eat soup and a 4” sandwich). After we got to the register, the person ringing us up said that we could NOT upgrade to ... read more
Jason L Woodbury via facebook.com - Nov 24, 2020
sandwiches are awesome - get the $20 24 inch one for the best deal ... maybe split it with a friend? management was pretty bad... I was chatting with girl working there and the manager was extremely rude about her wasting time talking to me, in front of me and another customer... the manager wouldn't let me talk to whoever was over ... read more
Clark W via google.com - Nov 13, 2020
The perfect sandwiches!  I custom ...
The perfect sandwiches!  I custom created a turkey with pepper jack and avocado and Gator Sauce and it was BOMB delicious!! Like a 5+ star sando.  The bread was so soft and perfect.

My husband had a panini style Mudder-in-Law that was great and the sides are delicious too!  Loaded potatoes (cute mini potatoes with cheese and b ... read more
Darlene C. via yelp.com - Nov 6, 2020
Love this place! The chicken teriyaki is my favorite item there! I love the staff there and will definitely be back.
Ryleigh Benke via google.com - Nov 3, 2020
The best flavors and unique sandwiches. You absolutely have to try the gator bites. The counter staff were very friendly and sociable. He walked me through all the options ... read more
Tim Deardeuff via google.com - Nov 3, 2020
I haven't been there forever! I was as good as I remembered. Their bread is the best! You should definitely try the funnel cake fries!
toni furniss via google.com - Oct 29, 2020
Delicious food!
Kylie Boyack via google.com - Oct 15, 2020
Awesome sandwiches staff very helpful to first timers.
Awesome sandwiches staff very helpful to first timers.
Corrie N Ben via facebook.com - Oct 10, 2020
The food is really good, you can definitely tell that’s its quality products and always fresh. The owner is also extremely nice. The only complaint I have are the employees who work there. They never seem to know what they’re doing, and I’ve had my order messed up several times. I think if you’re gonna work somewhere you should know ... read more
Lindsay Calhoun via google.com - Sep 10, 2020
Breakfast burritos are amazing!
Mike Jensen via google.com - Sep 10, 2020
Self-serve Dole whip for $2.11?!? Umm, yes! Best Dole whip deal in town! And, their sandwiches and sweet potato fries are phenomenal. 👌 Friendly staff and lots of yummy choices for food!
Paije Peck via google.com - Sep 9, 2020
Ohhhhh mannn! Back in 2014 when ...
Ohhhhh mannn! Back in 2014 when I use to live in pines I'll go every morning after my 7:45am class to eat their breakfast burrito. Ghosh I can never get over it lol ... read more
Akula N. via yelp.com - Sep 6, 2020
Good food ... read more
Jesse Hoffman via google.com - Aug 25, 2020
Biscuits and gravy for $3.49!
David Hoopes via google.com - Aug 11, 2020
So yum!
Sara R via google.com - Aug 8, 2020
GREAT STAFF! VERY NICE AND PROFESSIONAL. GREAT TERIYAKI BOWL!
Jaron Rose via google.com - Jul 28, 2020
The food is awesome and the people are great! We had a small problem with our order, not only did they fix it right away but they also gave us a couple freebies! Amazing customer service!
Austin Blair via google.com - Jul 25, 2020
Gator Jacks is my favorite sandwich place in town. The waffle fries are awesome. Best salad bar as well. Hopefully the pandemic is over soon so it will be back in the menu.
Erick Wills via google.com - Jul 21, 2020
I finished my sandwich and said ...
I finished my sandwich and said, "that was probably the best sandwich I've ever eaten!" It was so good! The girl who helped me was so nice, too, wonderful customer service. I would definitely recommend this place!
Erin P. via yelp.com - Jul 18, 2020
This is the place you want to go ...
This is the place you want to go for a variety of good things to eat. They have a salad bar, make fresh sandwiches, chicken popper baskets, fried pickles and a lot of other delicious items. My wife loves the chicken popper basket with sticky sauce and loves their fries. I always get a sandwich they make from scratch in front of you. ... read more
JD C. via yelp.com - Jul 10, 2020
The first time I went to GatorJacks was back on 2017. I go there every time I get the chance now. The atmosphere was better back then, now it doesn’t feel like a “gatorjacks”. But the food is still amazing. Best sandwich place ever. Better than subway, Quiznos, firehouse subs, you name it. And the Breakfast Burrito is THE BEST I HAVE ... read more
Cody Hansen via google.com - Jul 8, 2020
Really good food & friendly service! ...
Really good food & friendly service! Wish it wasn't as pricey, but the wife & I love going here for lunch or dinner with our friends!
Matthew R. via yelp.com - Jun 23, 2020
Yo, this place slaps. For real ...
Yo, this place slaps. For real. Their sandwiches are good. I've not e'er been disappointed in anything I've ordered, and they've got a lengthy menu! Their sides are bomb. Especially their sticky chicken bites and their fried pickles. And every meal comes with a cookie. Frickin' genius. The store is always clean and the staff is alway ... read more
Jarom J. via yelp.com - Jun 21, 2020
Good food. Fries were awesome.
Good food. Fries were awesome. My only complaints were some of the vegetables didn't look fresh and the toilet seat in the men's bathroom needs fixed.
Chris G. via yelp.com - Jun 18, 2020
Great sandwich, overpriced
I came here with my wife for lunch. I had a sandwich that had grilled chicken in it and it was surprisingly really good. It had to be one of the better sandwiches that I've had in recent weeks. The staff was very friendly and...More ... read more
sc0tty16 via tripadvisor.com - Jun 7, 2020
Best food in rexburg! Always loved the "Gator Bites" 🤤 ... read more
Norville Rogers via google.com - Jun 6, 2020
Great grab n go. I enjoy a local ...
Great grab n go. I enjoy a local sandwich shop compared to the chains.  Lot's of variety.  It tasted fresh ... read more
Ty R. via yelp.com - Jun 3, 2020
Always amazing tasting food ... read more
Russ Barnum via google.com - May 24, 2020
Great sandwiches and great members of our community!
Aaron Hussa via google.com - Apr 9, 2020
God be willing I don’t die from how obsessed I am with their cheese curds. Am I regular customer, u
God be willing I don’t die from how obsessed I am with their cheese curds. Am I regular customer, um hello yes. Will I return after graduation just for their cheese curds, also yes. One day I’ll venture further into their menu but right now I’m satisfied by the cheese alone. Pray for me.
Sabrina Lefort via facebook.com - Mar 29, 2020
thank you Gator Jack's! You guys are awesome. Great food and amazing staff.
thank you Gator Jack's! You guys are awesome. Great food and amazing staff.
Chant Williams via facebook.com - Mar 24, 2020
the service and people that work there make it worth it to go there but the food is delicious.
the service and people that work there make it worth it to go there but the food is delicious.
Christine Remington Erickson via facebook.com - Mar 20, 2020
Think 'gourmet subway' and you have a pretty good idea of what it is. Great spot for dates!
Blair M via google.com - Mar 10, 2020
My wife and I decided to try something ...
My wife and I decided to try something we hadn't yet in Rexburg and settled on Gator Jack's. I had pretty level-headed expectations when I placed our order for pickup.

I got the safe option of just a hot pastrami and their loaded gators (small potatoes with melted cheese and bacon). And my wife decided to be a little more adve ... read more
Ben V. via yelp.com - Mar 10, 2020
Great Sandwiches and Salad Bar
My wife really loves the Gator Jack's salad bar. She says it is the best in town. I personally like the Cluck-N-Nuts sandwich (chicken salad). The old Gator Jack's had a wonderful sourdough bread, but they no longer offer that type of bread, huge bummer....More ... read more
ReadyHiker via tripadvisor.com - Mar 3, 2020
Good food ... read more
Chuck Zbur via google.com - Feb 28, 2020
Nothing to complain about. Very diverse and delicious menu. I got the “mudda in law” sandwich and it was great. Tons of meat and cheese on my sandwich and the bread was superb, both of which are really what makes a great sandwich place.
Jackson Fisher via google.com - Feb 22, 2020
Fantastic place. We ordered Jack, Hobo Combo, and Murder? something, it was the name of sandwich menu. You choose the bread and meat, bacon, depending on which sandwich you get. You get to choose your veggies. They will ask if you want to grill, must do it! Workers were super nice, the interior was nice as well. 100 percent recommen ... read more
Shinjin Lee via google.com - Feb 20, 2020
Best breakfast burritos ever!!
Chris Black via google.com - Feb 18, 2020
Amazing place to eat! Love em!
Amazing place to eat! Love em!
Karen Hannah via facebook.com - Feb 13, 2020
Super good food. A big step up from Subway, and about the same price. One of the best sandwich places around.
The Coach via google.com - Jan 31, 2020
Best restaurant in Rexburg. Food is great and they don’t skimp out on the meat for the sandwiches/burritos.
Houston Collette via google.com - Jan 28, 2020
If you've ever been to Disneyland and have had the dole whip pineapple icecream and crave it look no more. This is the only place that I have found to have it outside of the park. A bonus, its self serve!
Scott Holmes via google.com - Jan 23, 2020
Delicious soup, clean, bright, and happy environment ... read more
Julia Clifford via google.com - Jan 19, 2020
Stopped here on our way back from ...
Stopped here on our way back from Yellowstone, WY. My sister said this was her favorite place to eat lunch when she lived in Rexburg.

Great variety of sandwiches and a nice salad bar. You can even watch "the game" in the bathroom. The place was very clean and modern.

They make these baby potatoes(gators) covered in ch ... read more
Benjamin B. via yelp.com - Jan 19, 2020
Been here more times than I am willing to admit but you know what? Worth it. Subway and Jimmy Johns got nothing on this spot. Change my mind ... read more
Ave Talauega via google.com - Jan 18, 2020
We have been several times and have always loved everything we have gotten. Our favorites are the soups, teriaki rice bowl and the Jack sandwich.
Tiffany Bean via google.com - Dec 28, 2019
Breakfast burritos are fabulous ... read more
Maren Tunks via google.com - Dec 19, 2019
Great service and taste ... read more
Ryan S Taylor via google.com - Dec 18, 2019
Dear heavens, I was blessed to visit this fantastic shop. It was an experience that I will never forget. I work in a basement, and gator jacks delicious cheese curds felt like the waterfalls of life. The fries revived my vigor for work day in and day out. They treated me well as they could see my job left me depressed and void of all ... read more
garek cooke via google.com - Dec 13, 2019
I come here often. Delicious food! The breakfast burrito is insanely good, along with the mudder -in-law. Deep fried cheese curds remind me of home (Wisconsin). The staff is always pleasant and this afternoon I felt they were exceptional (the three that I spoke with). The only problem you will have here is struggling to not eat the s ... read more
Eric via google.com - Dec 10, 2019
Great location, with some good food. Not anything outstanding, but it's clean and they have friendly staff. Better than your typical subway or Jimmy Johns sandwich IMO.
Katelyn McMaster via google.com - Dec 10, 2019
HUGE fan of the breakfast burritos, if you haven’t tried one you’re missing out. I usually get it with steak/bacon, add gator sauce. And the guy that makes my burrito is always so friendly ... read more
Franklin Ruiz via google.com - Dec 10, 2019
I went here with my cousin the ...
I went here with my cousin the other day and is was great. I loved the layout of the place and the food was excellent. I love the gator bites.
Kylie H. via yelp.com - Dec 9, 2019
Good sandwiches great salad bar.
Stephen Cook via google.com - Dec 5, 2019
The food is great! super friendly atmosphere and great location!
The food is great! super friendly atmosphere and great location!
Arielle Scott Terry via facebook.com - Nov 27, 2019
GREAT PEOPLE AND EVEN BETTER FOOD! TOTALLY RECOMMEND TO ANYONE IN THE AREA!!!! MUST TRY!!!
GREAT PEOPLE AND EVEN BETTER FOOD! TOTALLY RECOMMEND TO ANYONE IN THE AREA!!!! MUST TRY!!!
Ismael Cantu via facebook.com - Nov 12, 2019
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire