skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Really delicious sandwiches. The people who prepare the food are nice. It's like an authentic version of Subway ... read more
Ellis Panttaja via google.com - Jun 10, 2021
I've only gotten food here once. Employees were nice enough, it was fast but I'm just miffed cause they don't have soup. Maybe it's a seasonal thing but it was still on the sign, website and on-site menu. The Mac & Cheese is good I just think they need to make it clear that they are not selling soup at the moment.
Amy Zapalac via google.com - May 29, 2021
OMG! we love this place. Excellent food, great staff, clean spacious dining.
Tiffany Lavigne via google.com - May 22, 2021
The food is always really good.
Joshua Hughes via google.com - May 11, 2021
Delicious sandwiches, way better than Jimmy John's and Subway.
Zachary Fisher via google.com - Apr 23, 2021
We have always loved their food. We have always dined in. I was very disappointed when the one and only time I called my order in so I could pick it up on my way through town because I was in a hurry it took literally an hour from the time I called to when I got my food. It would have been faster to get in line when I got there and o ... read more
Eric Larson via google.com - Apr 10, 2021
I have had two different sandwiches- the French Dip and the Jack and both tasted amazing.
Kenton Jepsen via google.com - Apr 10, 2021
Great food at a reasonable price. Wonderful services.
Donnel T. via google.com - Apr 7, 2021
First time there today and I enjoyed it a lot. I had the Caiman sandwich which was unique and original. It had a cream cheese spread that melted down nice when it was roasted and pressed. I also had the chicken noodle soups which was very hearty. Great meal! Great service as well.
Jeremy Jacobs via google.com - Apr 7, 2021
Surprisingly low price for the good food we got. This time my group of 3 adults got in and out for like $26. And none of us even ordered the deeply discounted daily special. (Check out specials, because I have no idea how they afford to offer those deals.) I had the 8" French dip which was great. I had it pressed, but probably would ... read more
Todd Beck via google.com - Apr 3, 2021
This time my group of 3 adults got in and out for like $26. And none of us even ordered the deeply d
This time my group of 3 adults got in and out for like $26. And none of us even ordered the deeply discounted daily special. (Check out specials, because I have no idea how they afford to offer those deals.) I had the 8" French dip which was great. I had it pressed, but probably would just toast it next time. My son liked his Reuben ... read more
toddwarrenbeck via tripadvisor.com - Apr 3, 2021
Got the daily special. Mudder. It was very tasty. Bread was soft and fresh. Fries were really good. Kids loved the dole whip. Tried the gator bites and I love that they are actual little potatoes instead of tater tots. Great price for the amount of food you're given.
Misty Buck via google.com - Mar 30, 2021
Breakfast burritos are the best in town.
Kevin Bingham via google.com - Mar 25, 2021
I went in for my first visit because today they were offering a pay-25-get-35 gift card discount. Even though they were giving me free stuff they were super nice. Then I put in my phone number and, boom, more free stuff: A Dole Whip. Even so they acted like I was their best customer.
Todd Beck via google.com - Mar 19, 2021
I used my glass card app to try out the Gator Jack burritos. I just got home and bit into one and oh my goodness! That has got to be the best burrito I have ever had!!! The combinations of flavors, the texture, the moistness, it was wonderful. I'm hooked. I'll be going back off and for these.
Karla Spencer via google.com - Mar 17, 2021
What a great place, food was amazing, service was top notch, well done ... read more
Duke Turner via google.com - Feb 23, 2021
Best sandwich place in Rexburg! I've been there several times and they've always exceeded my expectations and satisfied me. Their desserts are delicious as well! You're missing out if you've never been here.
Joey Vogl via google.com - Feb 22, 2021
I love their Quesadillas and their Gator Sauce is the best!!!
Eduardo Alvarado via google.com - Feb 21, 2021
Awesome date spot.
Deric Duerksen via google.com - Feb 17, 2021
So good! Sandwiches left me feeling filled and refreshed.
Carlton Collins via google.com - Feb 10, 2021
Super good food and great service. The gator bites are potato though, not alligator, so a little misleading.
Jason Burton via google.com - Feb 3, 2021
Great place, loved breakfast burrito and French dip!!
Jessica Elisa Ambrose via google.com - Jan 25, 2021
Great food!!!💜 First time going here and definitely plan on returning!!
Deborah Brower via google.com - Jan 2, 2021
Used to go here years ago when it was under different management/ownership and the food was alright! BUT now I've gone back recently, it's improved A LOT. The breakfast burrito is the best I've had and I intent to return to try more of their menu items. Some of the prices are a bit high, but they do pack the burrito full so I hope t ... read more
Amy L via google.com - Dec 16, 2020
Good food! They also have good deals from time to time!
Nathan Webb via google.com - Dec 11, 2020
The food was good, but they did mess up 4 of our 6 orders. Menu says kids can upgrade to fries wit
The food was good, but they did mess up 4 of our 6 orders. Menu says kids can upgrade to fries with their kids mea for $.29, and the person taking our order said we could. We also ordered a combination (all you can eat soup and a 4” sandwich). After we got to the register, the person ringing us up said that we could NOT upgrade to ... read more
Jason L Woodbury via facebook.com - Nov 24, 2020
sandwiches are awesome - get the $20 24 inch one for the best deal ... maybe split it with a friend? management was pretty bad... I was chatting with girl working there and the manager was extremely rude about her wasting time talking to me, in front of me and another customer... the manager wouldn't let me talk to whoever was over ... read more
Clark W via google.com - Nov 13, 2020
The perfect sandwiches! I custom created a turkey with pepper jack and avocado and Gator Sauce and i
The perfect sandwiches! I custom created a turkey with pepper jack and avocado and Gator Sauce and it was BOMB delicious!! Like a 5+ star sando. The bread was so soft and perfect. My husband had a panini style Mudder-in-Law that was great and the sides are delicious too! Loaded potatoes (cute mini potatoes with cheese and bacon) and ... read more
Darlene C. via yelp.com - Nov 6, 2020
Love this place! The chicken teriyaki is my favorite item there! I love the staff there and will definitely be back.
Ryleigh Benke via google.com - Nov 3, 2020
The best flavors and unique sandwiches. You absolutely have to try the gator bites. The counter staff were very friendly and sociable. He walked me through all the options ... read more
Tim Deardeuff via google.com - Nov 3, 2020
I haven't been there forever! I was as good as I remembered. Their bread is the best! You should definitely try the funnel cake fries!
toni furniss via google.com - Oct 29, 2020
Delicious food!
Kylie Boyack via google.com - Oct 15, 2020
Awesome sandwiches staff very helpful to first timers.
Awesome sandwiches staff very helpful to first timers.
Corrie N Ben via facebook.com - Oct 10, 2020
The food is really good, you can definitely tell that’s its quality products and always fresh. The owner is also extremely nice. The only complaint I have are the employees who work there. They never seem to know what they’re doing, and I’ve had my order messed up several times. I think if you’re gonna work somewhere you should know ... read more
Lindsay Calhoun via google.com - Sep 10, 2020
Breakfast burritos are amazing!
Mike Jensen via google.com - Sep 10, 2020
Self-serve Dole whip for $2.11?!? Umm, yes! Best Dole whip deal in town! And, their sandwiches and sweet potato fries are phenomenal. 👌 Friendly staff and lots of yummy choices for food!
Paije Peck via google.com - Sep 9, 2020
Ohhhhh mannn! Back in 2014 when I use to live in pines I'll go every morning after my 7:45am class t
Ohhhhh mannn! Back in 2014 when I use to live in pines I'll go every morning after my 7:45am class to eat their breakfast burrito. Ghosh I can never get over it lol ... read more
Akula N. via yelp.com - Sep 6, 2020
Good food ... read more
Jesse Hoffman via google.com - Aug 25, 2020
Biscuits and gravy for $3.49!
David Hoopes via google.com - Aug 11, 2020
So yum!
Sara R via google.com - Aug 8, 2020
GREAT STAFF! VERY NICE AND PROFESSIONAL. GREAT TERIYAKI BOWL!
Jaron Rose via google.com - Jul 28, 2020
The food is awesome and the people are great! We had a small problem with our order, not only did they fix it right away but they also gave us a couple freebies! Amazing customer service!
Austin Blair via google.com - Jul 25, 2020
Gator Jacks is my favorite sandwich place in town. The waffle fries are awesome. Best salad bar as well. Hopefully the pandemic is over soon so it will be back in the menu.
Erick Wills via google.com - Jul 21, 2020
This is the place you want to go for a variety of good things to eat. They have a salad bar, make fr
This is the place you want to go for a variety of good things to eat. They have a salad bar, make fresh sandwiches, chicken popper baskets, fried pickles and a lot of other delicious items. My wife loves the chicken popper basket with sticky sauce and loves their fries. I always get a sandwich they make from scratch in front of you. ... read more
JD C. via yelp.com - Jul 10, 2020
The first time I went to GatorJacks was back on 2017. I go there every time I get the chance now. The atmosphere was better back then, now it doesn’t feel like a “gatorjacks”. But the food is still amazing. Best sandwich place ever. Better than subway, Quiznos, firehouse subs, you name it. And the Breakfast Burrito is THE BEST I HAVE ... read more
Cody Hansen via google.com - Jul 8, 2020
Good food. Fries were awesome. My only complaints were some of the vegetables didn't look fresh and
Good food. Fries were awesome. My only complaints were some of the vegetables didn't look fresh and the toilet seat in the men's bathroom needs fixed.
Chris G. via yelp.com - Jun 18, 2020
Great sandwich, overpriced
I came here with my wife for lunch. I had a sandwich that had grilled chicken in it and it was surprisingly really good. It had to be one of the better sandwiches that I've had in recent weeks. The staff was very friendly and...More ... read more
sc0tty16 via tripadvisor.com - Jun 7, 2020
Best food in rexburg! Always loved the "Gator Bites" 🤤 ... read more
Norville Rogers via google.com - Jun 6, 2020
Great grab n go. I enjoy a local sandwich shop compared to the chains. Lot's of variety. It tasted f
Great grab n go. I enjoy a local sandwich shop compared to the chains. Lot's of variety. It tasted fresh ... read more
Ty R. via yelp.com - Jun 3, 2020
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire